A similar species is the Short-tailed Shearwater, A. tenuirostris, which is smaller, with a smaller bill. Close up the Short-tailed has a more abrupt head profile, compared to the Sooty's flatter-crowned appearance and less obvious forehead. The Wedge-tailed Shearwater, A. pacifica, is quite different with smaller head and body, long slender wedge-shaped tail and long broad wings. Its flight is lazy and buoyant and does not have the bursts of stiff-winged fluttering of the Sooty. The Flesh-footed Shearwater, A. carneipes, has a heavier paler bill and broader wings than the Sooty, and has a more leisurely less flapping flight.