Swamp or Spotted or other

7 posts / 0 new
Last post
Rick N
Rick N's picture
Swamp or Spotted or other

Help needed please. Can't decide between Swamp Harrier or juvenile Spotted Harrier or other.

Taken 12-08-16 Strzelecki Track, 100kln North of Lyndhurst.

WhistlingDuck

Looks a good match for the first immature spotted harrier plummage as per the Birds of Prey of Australia field guide - although yours has a bit paler colours underneath. 

Excellent photos too.

HelloBirdy
HelloBirdy's picture

I can't shed any light on the ID but can't not comment on the quality of these photos! Just amazing

Ryu
Canberra
Aiming for DSLR-quality shots with a bridge camera

sue818
sue818's picture

Agree with juvenile Spotted Harrier but I am no expert. The tail barring is wide and bold where a Swamp Harrier appears to be narrow and shadowy as per Slater's and Pizzey & Knight guides. The neck collar'' also seems right. It is just like the picture in Birds of Australia by woods et al albeit a bit paler.

Love these learning exercises but the stunning photos make it so much easier. Well done, Rick.

Sue

Rick N
Rick N's picture

Thanks for your responses. Happy with juvenile Spotted Harrier.

Snail
Snail's picture

I agree with juvenile Spotted Harrier. The black wingtips are a good feature to look for combined with the thick black tail barring as mentioned by Sue. :) 

LM

Devster
Devster's picture

Well I just learned something. These are great exercises to do. Especially when you give reasons like Sue & LM.

 and   @birdsinbackyards
                 Subscribe to me on YouTube