ID Help Please....

8 posts / 0 new
Last post
akasha
akasha's picture
ID Help Please....

So who's up for a challange? I saw this one at Gum Swamp near Forbes NSW on the weekend. I have no idea what it is. It was a little bigger than a White-plumed Honeyeater. Thoughts? Thanks.

Araminta
Araminta's picture

I'd go for female Golden Whistler.

M-L

pacman
pacman's picture

+1 for Golden Whistler hen

Peter

Nahar
Nahar's picture

My vote is for the Golden whistler as well - female of course.

Owen1
Owen1's picture

I don't agree :) i reckon male Rufous whistler (inland form). Note the grey back compared to the more browny back of the golden. The wing coverts also have those exaggerated dark centres with pale edges while the golden lacks such distinct feathers. The Rufous Whistlers inland are much more pale so you would expect a lighter throat patch and buff on the belly as in the third photo.

Cheers, Owen.

pacman
pacman's picture

Owen1 wrote:

male Rufous whistler (inland form)

I can't see the black breast band that should continue acroos the face to the lores for a male bird

Peter

Owen1
Owen1's picture

Yes, quite correct, I'm thinking young male that hasn't developed the band yet because the female rufous has streaks.

Cheers, Owen.

Araminta
Araminta's picture

You are right Owen, (as you always are!), I did wonder about the grey instead of brown colour. Tanks Owen, I learned something.

M-L

 and   @birdsinbackyards
                 Subscribe to me on YouTube