With the light ring around the eye and the white wingbar it looks like a female Flame Robin; perhaps Scarlet, but Scarlet ladies tend to have a light red patch on the breast. I don't know how anyone could even confuse a robin with a whistler. The dumpy body and the bill shape, the behaviour (on ground) are so typical of any of our local robin species.
As Akos said , it is a bit too uniform grey all over to be a femaleScarlet Robin. I saw one this afternoon, there is some light red on their chest. Not a Scarlet.
Could be a female hooded robin with that wingbar - or maybe just another female golden whistler.
With the light ring around the eye and the white wingbar it looks like a female Flame Robin; perhaps Scarlet, but Scarlet ladies tend to have a light red patch on the breast. I don't know how anyone could even confuse a robin with a whistler. The dumpy body and the bill shape, the behaviour (on ground) are so typical of any of our local robin species.
As Akos said , it is a bit too uniform grey all over to be a femaleScarlet Robin. I saw one this afternoon, there is some light red on their chest. Not a Scarlet.
M-L